The Educator's PLN

The personal learning network for educators

During last Thursday’s ukedchat I engaged in a mild disagreement with Andrew Hall @ConsultantHead on the best way to organise classroom seating.

He defended the proposition that seating students in rows made behaviour management easier and would therefore lead to better teaching & learning. I begged to differ.

Part of the argument was that if students are mucking around then they’re unlikely to learn anything and unless they’re in neat, regimented rows they’ll muck around. This is not the place to reel off lists of wonderfully effective behaviour for learning techniques and I won’t disagree that it is easier to ‘control’ kids if they’re all sat facing you. The problem is that I’m not interested in trying to control students, I’m interested in engaging and motivating learners. Badly behaved, unmotivated students are students who cannot see any point in behaving. If I can (and I do) demonstrate what’s in it for students to behave and learn then, I’ll be able to trust them to get on with exciting lessons. And sit in groups.

My view is that everything that happens in the classroom (and beyond if possible) should be about learning. I’m sure few would argue with this. It has become a truism that teaching doesn’t necessarily lead to learning. One of my favourite quotes comes from Ian Gilbert’sEssential Motivation for the Classroom, “If you’re not learning, I’m just talking”. Teachers are supposed to be the ‘guide on the side not the sage on the stage’ and seating is just one small, but easy to manage part of the solution. If desks are in rows, students are forced to face front and whilst they can compare ideas with their desk partner, any kind of group discussion is made difficult. If tables are arranged in groups, collaborative group work becomes an almost inevitable part of lessons.

I can find no better advocate of my position than Phil Beadle. In his excellent book How To Teach, he says,

“Having your desks set out in groups is the right way to organise your classroom. Period. No discussion. No arguing.  Having the tables in groups allows you to set them grouped speaking and listening activities that are the way they learn most effectively. Having your table in groups lets them learn from each other. And having your tables in groups is a spatially symbolic move away from the Dickensian notion of the teacher standing at the front talking cobblers about really hard sums all day, every day.”

Try as I might, I can find nothing to disagree with here. Everything I know to be true about managing students and getting them to learn stuff needs them to be sitting in groups, facing each other rather than me. In an ideal world I’d like to be able to infinitely vary my groupings and would love my desks to be singles rather than doubles to facilitate moving them around more often. The truth is that moving desks about is a drag (literally) and I can’t be bothered to do it several times a day let alone several times a lesson.

However, I do put a lot of thought into the way I group my tables. I finished last year with 8 groups of 4 but have decided to start September with 5 groups of 6. This means that activities can be easily mixed up so that it is easy to move from paired discussion, a group of three and then a larger group of up to 6 without dragging desks about. Also, it’s makes good use of the space in my classroom and leaves a central space for students to engage in exciting kinaesthetic learning.

My old seating plan
My new seating plan

I’m not saying there’s never a place for desks laid out in rows, there is: exam halls.

Nifty room layout pics are curtsy of http://classroom.4teachers.org/

Views: 136

Comment

You need to be a member of The Educator's PLN to add comments!

Join The Educator's PLN

Comment by David Didau on August 26, 2011 at 2:35pm
See more of my blog at learningspy.edublogs.org

About

Thomas Whitby created this Ning Network.

Latest Activity

Alice Thomas posted a blog post

Why is it so important to write a quality MBA essay?

Writing a persuasive and quality MBA essay is one of the essential stages in the MBA application process. It is an examination phrase where you have to include different information in your essay. This article will explain the importance of writing a quality MBA essay and provide insights into the explored topic. Suppose you require the right information about writing quality MBA essays and improve your general understanding. In that case, you are in the appropriate location because this…See More
Nov 20
Profile IconMaxBurton, Andrew Hickman, Ellis Leigh and 9 more joined The Educator's PLN
Nov 19
Jamie Costello posted a blog post

Top tips to increase your productivity through your study room

We’re stuck at home with limited access to many public spaces outdoors, including libraries, co-working spaces and educational institutions. These are just some examples of study areas you may utilise when you need a change in scenery to keep yourself engaged whilst you’re studying. Now, we’re being forced within the four walls of our home which means creating a workspace or room has never been more important. The learning environment that students work in can have a major impact on…See More
Nov 10
Profile IconWalter Holz, Sarah Kerttu, Gaby Eyzaguirre and 5 more joined The Educator's PLN
Nov 4
john smith updated their profile
Oct 30
Jamie Costello posted a blog post

3 Best Educational Apps for Student

When we think of mobile phones in the classroom, it tends to be a forbidden subject as teachers found them as a distraction against education. Parents and teachers would do anything to prevent the use of smartphones in the classroom.  Now we’re seeing a different outlook on the benefits of mobile phones in the classroom. In particular, mobile app development is shedding a light on how mobile phones can actually be the key to educational…See More
Sep 30
Agnes Mckenna updated their profile
Sep 29
Eleonore Cowan updated their profile
Sep 29

Events

© 2020   Created by Thomas Whitby.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service